Why Desert Sand is Not Suitable for Construction: A Detailed Examination

/by

Desert sand presents a unique set of challenges when considered for construction purposes. While it may appear to be a viable option due to its abundance and fine texture, several inherent characteristics make it unsuitable for construction. This article delves into these characteristics, explores the specific issues associated with desert sand, and compares it to other types of sand that are more appropriate for construction.

Characteristics of Desert Sand

1. Fine Grain Size

Desert sand is often known for its fine grain size. This fine texture, while seemingly advantageous, poses several issues for construction:

  • Lack of Angularity: Unlike other types of sand, desert sand grains are typically smooth and rounded due to extensive weathering. This lack of angularity affects how well the sand bonds with cement and aggregates, leading to weaker concrete and mortar mixtures.
  • Poor Compaction: The fine and rounded nature of desert sand results in poor compaction, which can lead to unstable and less durable construction.

2. High Silica Content

Desert sand is rich in silica, which is a key component in many types of sand. However, the high silica content in desert sand can lead to:

  • Decreased Strength: The fine, uniform silica particles can contribute to a decrease in the overall strength of concrete and mortar. While silica itself is not harmful, the fine particle size can adversely affect the bonding properties of the sand.
  • Increased Abrasiveness: High silica content can also make the sand more abrasive, potentially causing wear and tear on construction equipment and tools.

3. Poor Chemical Composition

The chemical composition of desert sand can lead to various issues:

  • High Salt and Mineral Content: Desert sand can contain elevated levels of salts and other minerals that may react with cement and other materials, causing deterioration over time. This is especially problematic in areas with high humidity or in environments prone to moisture.
  • Incompatibility with Cement: The chemical composition of desert sand may not always be compatible with the cement used in concrete, potentially leading to adverse chemical reactions that compromise the integrity of the construction.

Issues with Using Desert Sand in Construction

1. Durability Problems

Durability is a critical factor in construction, and desert sand can significantly impact it:

  • Increased Corrosion: The presence of salts and minerals in desert sand can accelerate the corrosion of steel reinforcement in concrete, reducing the lifespan and structural integrity of the construction.
  • Weathering and Erosion: Concrete and mortar made with desert sand may be more susceptible to weathering and erosion due to the fine and rounded nature of the sand grains.

2. Structural Weaknesses

Using desert sand in construction can lead to various structural weaknesses:

  • Weaker Bonding: The smooth, rounded grains of desert sand do not bond as effectively with cement, leading to weaker concrete and mortar mixes. This can result in structures that are less stable and more prone to failure.
  • Reduced Load-Bearing Capacity: The overall load-bearing capacity of structures using desert sand may be lower compared to those using more suitable types of sand.

3. Maintenance and Repair Issues

Structures built with desert sand may face higher maintenance and repair costs:

  • Frequent Repairs: The increased likelihood of deterioration and structural weaknesses can lead to more frequent repairs and maintenance.
  • Increased Upkeep: The need for additional maintenance to address issues arising from the use of desert sand can lead to increased long-term costs.

Alternative Sands for Construction

To avoid the issues associated with desert sand, construction professionals often use other types of sand that offer better performance and durability:

1. River Sand

River sand is preferred for construction due to its cleanliness and uniform texture. It typically has a mix of fine and coarse particles, which provides good workability and bonding properties.

  • Smooth and Rounded Grains: River sand’s rounded grains offer good compaction and bonding with cement and aggregates.
  • Lower Impurities: It generally has lower levels of impurities compared to desert sand, leading to better performance in construction applications.

2. Concrete Sand

Concrete sand is a coarser type of sand that is produced by crushing rocks and has angular grains that provide excellent bonding with cement.

  • Angular Grains: The angularity of concrete sand enhances the bonding and strength of concrete mixes.
  • High Strength: It is ideal for use in concrete production due to its ability to provide the necessary strength and stability.

3. Mason Sand

Mason sand is a fine, clean sand used primarily for mortar and finishing applications. It offers a uniform texture and cleanliness that makes it suitable for masonry work.

  • Fine Texture: Its fine texture is ideal for applications requiring a smooth finish.
  • Consistency: Mason sand’s uniformity ensures consistent performance in masonry applications.

4. Sharp Sand

Sharp sand, or grit sand, is characterized by its rough, angular grains and is used in various construction applications.

  • Rough Texture: Sharp sand’s rough texture enhances its ability to bond with other materials, making it suitable for concrete and landscaping.
  • Versatility: It is used in a variety of applications, including mixing with cement and as a base for paving.

Conclusion

Desert sand presents several challenges that make it unsuitable for construction. Its fine grain size, high silica content, and poor chemical composition contribute to durability issues, structural weaknesses, and increased maintenance costs. To achieve optimal performance and durability in construction, it is advisable to use alternative types of sand such as river sand, concrete sand, mason sand, and sharp sand.